Movie Review: Bhopal — A Prayer for Rain (2014)

Bhopal_a_prayer_for_rain_poster3 Stars (out of 4)

Buy or rent the movie at iTunes
Buy the DVD at Amazon

The 1984 industrial disaster at a Union Carbide pesticide plant in Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, isn’t a common reference in the United States the way that the Chernobyl nuclear disaster is, but it’s an event Americans should be aware of. Bhopal: A Prayer for Rain depicts a catastrophe of almost unbelievable proportions.

In 1969, American company Union Carbide builds a plant in the central Indian city of Bhopal to produce agricultural chemicals. By 1984, the decrepit plant situated in the middle of a slum struggles to make ends meet, as a drought decreases the market for the company’s products. One night in December of that year, a gas leak from the plant exposes a half-million Bhopal residents to toxic fumes.

The story of the tragedy is told from several perspectives, including those of Motwani (Kal Penn), a journalist desperate to warn the city of impending danger, and Roy (Joy Sengupta), a plant safety officer trying to prevent a disaster in the face of unsympathetic management, failing equipment, and unqualified staff.

At the film’s heart is Dilip (Rajpal Yadav), a rickshaw driver who quickly ascends from plant janitor to equipment safety monitor. He’s as unqualified for the job as everyone else at the plant, but he’s a devoted employee.

Dilip personifies the conundrum of the plant’s existence. There aren’t enough trained engineers available to operate the equipment, especially for the wages Carbide can pay in an unprofitable market. But Dilip’s meager paycheck is enough to lift his family out of dire poverty. Closing the plant permanently would economically devastate the city.

In the film, the events of the disaster coincide with the wedding of Dilip’s younger sister, an event made possible by the same company ultimately responsible for killing thousands and injuring scores of thousands more.

Though the filmmakers take sides regarding the cause of the disaster — citing corporate negligence as opposed to Carbide’s official attribution to sabotage by a disgruntled worker — the portrayal of the key figures is nuanced. Carbide’s CEO, Warren Anderson (Martin Sheen), expresses his desire to continue the social progress made possible by the Green Revolution of the 1960s. He’s proud of the economic opportunity the plant provides for the citizens of Bhopal.

Yet it takes a special kind of callousness to enable the circumstances that lead to the disaster. Anderson and Carbide refuse to admit that the chemical being manufactured in Bhopal — MIC — is dangerous to humans. Who would work there if it was? This denial leaves the ramshackle local hospital unequipped to handle an industrial disaster and gives most of the employees an unwarranted sense of security. If they were in danger, surely someone would tell them, right?

Perhaps the most chilling aspects of the story are the mechanisms are already in place to shield Carbide from corporate responsibility. The plant is technically run by an Indian subsidiary, so it’s the subsidiary’s fault for hiring untrained workers and letting the machines fall apart. It’s the subsidiary’s fault for failing to prepare for an accident that Carbide said couldn’t happen.

Scenes showing the night of the disaster are haunting not just because of the human suffering but because of the context in which it takes place. A deadly cloud blows through a shanty town of nearly half a million people going about their daily lives. As wedding guests start to fall ill, the expression in Dilip’s sister’s eyes is not fear of imminent doom but frustration: “Why is this happening on my special day?”

Performances in the film are generally good, especially Sheen’s role as Anderson. Mischa Barton’s turn as an American journalist is awkward and poorly integrated into the story. Though only the Hindi dialogue is subtitled, there are enough strong accents — including Kal Penn’s Indian accent and that of a European Carbide executive — that perhaps the English dialogue should’ve been subtitled as well.

Thirty years after the Bhopal disaster, industrial accidents caused by corporate irresponsibility are still too common all over the world. Bhopal: A Prayer for Rain implores us to (paraphrasing George Santayana) remember the past, so that we may stop repeating it.

Links

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Movie Review: Bhopal — A Prayer for Rain (2014)

  1. vinod

    yes it was one of the most sad moments for people. you can say it was nuclear attack for India like Japan but sure magnitude was not as dangerous as it was in Japan.

    Reply
    1. Kathy Post author

      It’s such a sad story, Vinod, because of how often it repeats itself all over the world, with varying degrees of human suffering. It reminded me of a factory explosion that destroyed a small town in Texas last year. That was no where near as deadly as Bhopal, but it was another case where people assumed that, if they were in danger, someone would’ve told them. That some authority somewhere would have protected them from a corporation that only cared about profits. It’s frustrating that we haven’t learned anything in the 30 years since Bhopal.

      Reply
  2. JustMeMike

    I’m looking forward to this one and that’s thanks to your fine review.

    No sign of it playing any where nearby at the moment, but it is likely that the Burns Court Cinema might get it.

    No sign of the DVD either. Amazon says they’ll have it in February. I looked for it on eBay and there was a DVD available. from Greece, and without English subtitles. While I presume that I won’t need subtitles for Mr. Sheen’s English – but per your well thought out review, the only subtitles are for the Hindi spoken scenes.

    Reply
    1. Kathy Post author

      Thanks for the kind words, Mike. Since it just came out in both India and the U.S (albeit in a very limited run), February sounds about right for Bhopal on DVD. Unless you want to brush up on your Greek… 😉

      Reply
    1. Kathy Post author

      It ended its run at Facets on December 4, David. I think its theatrical run in the U.S. is over, so you probably have to wait for Netflix or the DVD release in February.

      Reply
  3. Pingback: Streaming Video News: February 17, 2015 | Access Bollywood

  4. Pingback: This Week at the Movies, Part 2 (Dec. 12-14) | Online Film Critics Society

  5. Pingback: Streaming Video News: August 10, 2016 | Access Bollywood

  6. Pingback: Bollywood Box Office: September 23-25, 2016 | Access Bollywood

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s